Re: Packard versus the Rest

Posted by Rusty O\'Toole On 2010/12/6 19:28:40
Quote:

clipper47 wrote:
I am by no means an expert on Packards or any other car and I have limited experience with working on old cars. The one thing more than any other that strikes me about Packard and what makes them stand out from mediocre cars is the engineering, perhaps even over engineering of things which one cannot often see but which contribute to durability over time. On many occasions when taken something as simple as the clutch linkage apart I noticed that Packard used bearings and not simple bushings and made provision to lubricate these parts. The supports for the transmission and frame, the huge nine main bearings supporting that enormous crankshaft, the use of fine thread bolts ( I didn't break one when I restored my car!) are some of the things which set Packard apart from the "bean counter" companies including GM. The only other make of car that I am familiar with that even comes close is Mercedes-Benz.
Alas as H.L Mencken once said;
"Nobody ever went broke underestimating the taste of the American public." but some perhaps overestimated that taste of the consumer by thinking that engineering and quality would sell cars and so Packard died.


If you examined a Chrysler from the same era I think you would find many parallels. They also featured fine design and fine quality. I am thinking in particular of a 1951 Hemi V8 New Yorker I used to own. Like the Packard it was put together with fine thread studs and nuts, not coarse thread bolts. The castings were fine grained. As Tom McCahill stated, if you examine a Chrysler piece by piece, every part looks like it costs more money than the corresponding part on competitive makes. Packard and Chrysler even bought their bodies from the same supplier.

I am familiar with Mercedes cars of the fifties and sixties. They were even better built than the Packard and Chrysler. In fact in some ways I believe they went too far in making things unnecessarily elaborate and expensive but the quality was unquestionably there.

This Post was from: https://packardinfo.com/xoops/html/modules/newbb/viewtopic.php?post_id=66070