Quote:
...According to the quotes you posted, the person said the Fram Extra Gard was inferior because it now had cardboard end caps...
He mentioned cardboard end caps. In the original as well as in the unchanged quotation it reads:
"...It features cardboard end caps for the filter element that are glued in place...". Your statement seems to be afflicted with an interpretation.
Quote:
...As I showed in another forum, Fram filters form the 50's-today had cardboard end caps glued in place. Sio if Fram used to be a quality filter manufacturer and he contends it no longer is, what's the big deal with the end caps...
You showed that specific Fram filters from 50 - today had cardboard end caps glued in place. The implied supposition that all Fram filters from 50 - today had cardboard end caps glued in place seems to be based on a belief.
Quote:
...He is practicing guilt by insunuation, an art perfected by Sen Joseph McCarthy. You will please note that he does not state or even speculate what is wrong with cardboard end caps, just having them is bad enough....or back in the 50's very good. Will he please make up his mind??...
I noted that he doesn't state or even speculate what is wrong with cardboard end caps. I additionally noted that you stated or speculated that just having them would be bad. That seems to be a consequential error perhaps based on a misbelief potentially afflicted with a misinterpretation.
Quote:
...Her states different construction of different filters, but has no failure of filter or engines to back up supposed quality issues. His qualifications?? Licensed professional engineer, automotive engineer specializing in engines?? Glen Beck's understudy, Groucho's understudy??
Yes, he states different constructions of different filters. Just like you. And he additionally states that
"...These pages are NOT to be taken as gospel...". Permit me to remark that exactly this certain degree of humility seems to depart from your standard.
He frankly states his full name, his qualification and even his motivation. How about reading the words of a man before damning him - a prozedure which seems to revive certain work ethics of Sen Joseph McCarthy. As far as known Joseph McCarthy hasn't been an oil filter specialist.
This Post was from: https://packardinfo.com/xoops/html/modules/newbb/viewtopic.php?post_id=85041